Medicare: Too Many Liars, Too Few Leaders

First of a Three Part Series

The political-media establishment often cites Medicare as a “popular” example of the benefits of activist government, unrestrained by Constitutional limits.  But in a rational world Medicare would be seen as a monument to progressive myths, deceptions and failures.
In 1965 President Lyndon Johnson traveled to the Missouri home of former President Harry Truman for an emotional media event celebrating enactment of Medicare.  The two of them repeated some of the preposterous talking points that had helped sell the Medicare scheme to the Congress and the public.

Truman was first to speak:

This is an important hour for the Nation, for those of our citizens who have completed their tour of duty and have moved to the sidelines…These people are entitled, among other benefits, to the best medical protection available.

Then Johnson took over:

…through this new law, every citizen will be able, in his productive years when he is earning, to insure himself against the ravages of illness in his old age….

The genius of Medicare – from the point of view of progressives – is how quickly and irrevocably it ensnared the generations in government dependency.  The elderly immediately began receiving subsidized health care and were immediately grateful to Democrats.  Those who were working and paying the bill might have been more resistant except they were told they were buying “insurance” that would care for them in retirement – and it was amazingly cheap insurance.  More from Johnson’s speech of 1965

During your working years, the people of America–you–will contribute through the social security program a small amount each payday for Medicare insurance protection.  For example, the average worker in 1966 will contribute about $1.50 per month. The employer will contribute a similar amount…And through this new law every citizen will be able, in his productive years when he is earning, to insure himself against the ravages of illness in his old age.

Adjusted for inflation, Johnson’s $1.50 per month would be about $10.00 now.  So today, the Johnson promise, adjusted for inflation, would be a combined employer-employee Medicare cost of $20 per month for the “average worker.”  But, with the current Medicare payroll tax rate, and today’s average salary of  about $50,000,  the cost is $121 per month, six times what Johnson promised.

But it gets worse.  Johnson lied.   In no way does Medicare resemble insurance.  It’s just another welfare program that transfers income from workers to retirees.  Beginning on the first day in 1966 all revenue from the payroll tax was immediately spent on medical services for current retirees.  When each American reaches retirement age the taxes collected from those who are still working pay for his/her Medicare benefits.

As the chart shows Medicare revenue, from the payroll tax plus “insurance premiums” taken from seniors, isn’t nearly enough to support the program.  Deficits are projected to continue growing without end.

Because Medicare exists most Americans believe they are paying for and will be entitled to health care in retirement and do not invest in a genuine insurance program.  Few if any politicians are honorable enough to tell them the truth, that Medicare is a fraud.

Medicare is Unconstitutional and based entirely on lies.  But it cannot be undone without denying millions of people part or all of the health care they have been promised in exchange for their tax dollars. But it can not be sustained in its present form either.  So, a few courageous Congressmen, led by Budget Chairman Paul Ryan have presented a relatively simple and workable change that would stop the bleeding.

We’ll discuss the Ryan proposal in our next Medicare article.

The response from all the Democrats, some Republicans and most of the media has been an attempt to use the Medicare crisis to strengthen the liberal/progressive grip on government by claiming that Ryan’s intent is to leave seniors with no medical care at all.  This response is utterly devoid of honesty or concern for the future of Medicare.  It’s calculated to achieve one goal: scare and deceive voters, especially seniors, so they’ll re-elect Barack Obama and Senate Democrats.

Democrats support their position by pointing to polls that show majorities would rather continue Medicare as it is than accept major changes.  But these polls are dishonest.  They’re like asking a man who lost his job and then exhausted his savings if he would rather maintain his current life style without any income or find another job.

Continuing Medicare in its current form is not an option.  Major change is required to prevent draconian cuts in medical services in the future.  Treacherous, unprincipled politicians who recklessly fire up fear and emotion instead of dealing with the Medicare crisis deserve to be voted out of office at the earliest possible opportunity.

2 Comments so far

  1. Thousand Flowers Blooming on May 27th, 2011

    This is an outrageous lie. Medicare is not “a fraud.” It has cared for millions of seniors. It is what a modern, advanced society owes it’s senior citizens.

    Republican plans to gut Medicare will be their undoing. They’ve already lost the next election

  2. Hoosier-Jack on May 29th, 2011

    Paul Ryan doesn’t understand how seniors live in this country or how important Medicare is to their well being.