Bin Laden Photos Will Not Be Published

On Wednesday The White House announced President Obama decision not to release any photos of Osama bin Laden’s body.  Under the law The President has absolute and sole authority over the photos and whether or not to make them public.

Nobody has been more critical of President Obama than Liberty Works.  We would aggressively argue against his decision if there were a compelling case in favor of release.  But we don’t see such a case.

Some are demanding public release to confirm the fact that bin Laden is indeed dead.  But the Administration and the Pentagon have described methods used to confirm his identity that were far superior to presenting a photo to the general public.  There are two possibilities:

  1. Reality is as the administration has described it: Bin Laden was shot dead, the body was identified by witnesses in the compound, by DNA, and by facial recognition software and then buried at sea.
  2. It’s all a lie.  This possibility is too implausible to take seriously given the hundreds of people, both military and civilian, who would have to be conscious, involuntary participants in the conspiracy.

Anyone who still doesn’t believe bin Laden is dead would likely not be convinced by a photo of a heavily bearded man whose head or face was disfigured  by a bullet.  The negative consequences of releasing photos would include:

  • The photo(s) would appear on thousands of websites with all sorts of bizarre, pernicious “enhancements.”
  • Scores of Internet conspiracy mills would contrive pixel by pixel analysis purporting to “prove” Photoshop mischief.

Obama’s professed concern for Muslim sensibilities seems a bit silly, coming after he ordered the assault on a compound in a Muslim nation, where bin Laden was deliberately killed.

But, there don’t appear to be any convincing arguments in favor of publishing a photo of the corpse.

3 Comments so far

  1. Drew on May 6th, 2011

    As any reader of this excellent blogsite knows, BoomerJeff and I are pretty much kindred spirits, sharing a common worldview on many topics.

    However, on this point I have a different point of view. Put simply, the US has a rich history – and I think it is the appropriate posture – of transparency. The photos should be available for that reason, and that reason alone. The case for NOT releasing must be made. As Boomer points out, concerns about Muslim sensibilities are ridiculous. Those who want to hate us do, and will. Further, these photos will eventually come out. There are no secrets.

    I know there are those who might scoff and say, “transparency? what about the Gulf of Tonkin” etc. This just makes my point. Transparency is the correct policy. You want to avoid this.

    That all said, I am not at all surprised at the Administration’s decision. The promised “most transparent administration ever” has been anything but. Chicago street thugs is more like it. Anyone see what’s going on with Holder right now??

    And the beat goes on.

  2. Velia on May 7th, 2011

    Major follower of your page, a lot of your posts have really helped me out. Looking towards news!

  3. Cary on May 8th, 2011

    Nice write, I am viewing back frequently to watch out for improvements.